Ask any dealership what kind of buyer is easiest to close and you’ll hear the same answer: trade-in customers. These people aren’t window-shopping. They’ve already decided to part ways with their current vehicle, which means they’re deep into the buying process. So why do dealerships bury the trade-in value form at the bottom of a contact page? Or forget to promote it entirely?

Here’s the truth: you don’t need to discount every car on your lot to drive more business. You need to surface the right buying triggers. Few are more powerful than trade-in value. Here are 7 ways to generate more trade-in leads without turning your profit margin upside down.

1. Put Your Trade-In Offer Front and Center

If your trade-in form or tool is hard to find, most customers won’t bother. They’ll head to a national car site or competitor who makes it easier. Instead, your trade-in offer should be front and center, including:

• On your homepage

• Displayed on every vehicle listing

• Linked from your main navigation

• Integrated into your lead forms

Don’t hide it in the footer. Make it obvious.

Pro tip: Use action-driven language. “What’s your car worth?” or “Get your instant trade-in estimate” performs far better than “Trade Appraisal.”

2. Promote Your Trade-In Tool in Ads

Most dealerships run ads focused on promotions, inventory or finance specials. However, trade-in-specific ads often convert better. That’s because they target action-takers who are already thinking about making a move.

Ad angles that work well:

“Thinking about trading in? See what your car’s worth in 30 seconds.”

“8/10 people underestimate the value of their car. Find out how much yours is worth today!”

“Your current vehicle could be your down payment. Get an instant quote.”

Run these ads on Facebook, Instagram and Google Search. Just make sure your landing page is simple and offers a clear CTA.

3. Capture Interest With a Dedicated Landing Page

Dealership websites are hectic. There’s tons happening and prospects have to make a decision. Instead, every dealership should have a standalone landing page pushing trade-ins. Here’s what to include:

• A powerful headline that highlights the benefit

• Simple breakdown of how the trade-in process works

• A tool, calculator or form to estimate the value

Optional upgrade: integrate real-time appraisal tools

Why a separate page? Because it gives you a place to drive ad traffic, email clicks and social links without distractions. This enables you to keep your message tailored to trade-in leads.

4. Offer a Bonus Without Lowering Vehicle Prices

Discounting the car too much can kill your margin. But increasing the value of the trade-in is often seen as a win by the customer, even if the net result is the same.

Try messaging like:

“Get $700 above market value on your trade this weekend”

“Exclusive bonus for trade-in buyers this month only”

“We’ll match your CarMax offer and beat it by $250 (or more)”

It’s all about framing. People want to feel like they’re winning. Tade-in value is a great place to give them that feeling.

5. Include Trade-In CTAs in Your Email Campaigns

Have a big list of past leads or previous buyers? Don’t let it sit idle.Run a monthly or quarterly email campaign with a simple message about trade-ins:

“Thinking about an upgrade? Your current vehicle could be worth more than you think.”

“Used car values are still strong. Find out what yours is worth.”

“Trade up without breaking your budget. Gt your instant estimate now.”

These campaigns work well around tax season, before back-to-school or heading into winter. Sprinkle in seasonal messaging to make it feel relevant and customized.

6. Make the Trade-In Process Look Easy and Risk-Free

For many buyers, the trade-in process feels vague. Is it fast? Will I be lowballed? Will they try to pressure me into buying?

Address those objections head-on with language like:

“No obligation. Get your value and take your time.”

“We’ll buy your car even if you don’t buy from us.”

“Fast, accurate and fair. Trade in your car in 20 minutes.”

Better yet, show the process. Use a quick video or testimonial that walks through the steps, showing just how low-stress it can be.

7. Use Retargeting to Stay in Front of Visitors

Someone visits your site. Starts checking trade-in value. Then gets distracted and leaves. That’s not a lost lead: that’s a perfect candidate for a second chance. Run retargeting ads on Facebook, Instagram and Google Display Network with reminders like:

“Still thinking about your trade-in? Get your free estimate in seconds.”

“Your car could be your best down payment. See how much it’s worth.”

“Let’s finish what you started: schedule a zero-pressure appraisal today.”

These subtle nudges can bring back leads who were right on the edge of taking action. Maybe life got busy and they postponed taking the next step, but the right messaging serves as a gentle reminder.

Don’t Just Wait for Buyers. Activate Them.

There are plenty of people out there ready to make a move, but they need a reason to start. A strong trade-in message gives them that reason. It’s not about pushing. It’s about opening the door and making it as easy and friction-free as possible.

At Slamdot, we help dealerships build digital strategies that turn interest into action. That means optimized websites, trade-in tools that convert and revenue-generating campaigns.

With two decades of experience serving car dealerships, we know what moves the needle. Most importantly, our expert team cares about one thing only: delivering qualified leads to your sales team.

Want to see how? Contact us today for a free proposal!

See More Helpful Tips